Abstract
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) is utilized in this article to examine the intricate process of identity renegotiation that former combatants undergo when they transition from the military to civilian life. This statement underscores the considerable obstacles veterans face in acclimating to civilian standards, thereby illuminating the profound impact of military culture on individual identity. Through comprehensive interviews, most notably with a participant identified as Colin, this study effectively depicts the fundamental challenges that veterans encounter upon discharge: the erosion of community, structure, and purpose. The paper emphasizes the significance of customized interventions and support to aid in the reintegration of veterans. It also highlights the need for additional research with a broader range of participants to deepen understanding of this pivotal phase of life.
Introduction
I have documented the challenging period of self-renewal that many veterans face as they transition to civilian life after serving in the military. In my study, grounded in academic fields such as veteran studies and military sociology, I explore the distinct challenges individuals face during this crucial period of transition. One challenge is adapting to civilian life after leaving the military, where individuals may experience feelings of isolation and exclusion due to the absence of strict military routines and regulations. They encounter numerous obstacles as they adapt to this transition and strive to form a new sense of self (Endicott, 2022). The training and experiences that service members undergo significantly influence their personality, ethics, conduct, and self-perception. These individuals face the significant task of redefining their identity beyond the military sphere as they transition out of service.
Methods
Methodology
My study’s methodology relies on Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA). I find IPA a valuable approach to gain insight into individuals’ lived experiences during important life transitions. This strategy aims to understand how individuals perceive and respond to significant life events. It is grounded in the phenomenological method in psychology (Endicott, 2022). My use of IPA underscores the importance of documenting participants’ subjective experiences (Endicott, 2022).
Data Collection
The primary source of data for my analysis is transcripts of interviews with a male veteran, whom I refer to as Colin. Colin’s testimony thoughtfully illustrates the obstacles individuals face when returning to normal life after lengthy military service. I conducted a semi-structured interview as part of my comprehensive qualitative study on the reevaluation of identity in war veterans. The flexibility of this format allowed me to thoroughly explore crucial topics of inquiry. Colin’s responses enhanced the theoretical insights by providing a true and practical perspective, which made the results more authentic and useful (Dolan et al., 2022). Understanding the complex cognitive and emotional factors at play while changing one’s identity is essential.
Data Analysis
The data analysis process in IPA consists of iteration and induction, as well as profound, reflective engagement with the text. Reading and rereading the interview transcript in the first stage helps me gain a thorough comprehension of what the interviewee said. To conduct further analysis, I need to develop thorough preliminary notes that are precise, linguistic, and conceptual in nature (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). The goal of these notes is to identify recurring themes that capture the core of the participant’s experience (Endicott, 2022). I then organize these themes, explore their relationships, and integrate them into a narrative illustrating the participant’s process of renegotiating their identity (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). I maintain an ongoing, reflective dialogue with the text throughout the procedure.
Ethics
Ethics plays a critical role in my research, particularly when sensitive topics, such as renegotiating identity after military service, are investigated. The participants in my research were treated with respect, their information was kept confidential, and they gave informed consent (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). I provided a comprehensive overview of the study’s objectives, methodologies, and potential results to “Colin” prior to the interview. After receiving comprehensive information about his rights, including the right to withdraw from the study at any time, Colin consented. To safeguard participants’ identities and personal information, I implemented privacy protocols (Meca et al., 2021).
Results and Major Themes
It is important to note that the first main theme is identity and self-perception after service. This is followed by two subthemes needed to assess the military’s impact on self-identity and to redefine self outside of military life. The next theme is overcoming the loss of community and structure. Sub-themes are the role of the community in military identity and adjusting to the lack of organizational support in civilian life. Veterans often face problems of not being accepted by society after participating in military operations, and society cannot always help them adapt.
Identity and Self-Perception Post-Service
The Military’s Influence on Self-Identity
My comprehensive analysis of the dialogue with “Colin,” an army veteran, revealed several significant themes that underpin the process of reestablishing one’s sense of self following discharge from the armed forces. Colin explains, “everything that’s brought me to this point is in those twenty-five years… I consider myself to be an ex-soldier. I’m proud to be an ex-soldier, to have served, very proud” (p 2, lane 20).
The key themes from Colin’s story shed light on the challenges many ex-soldiers face in reintegrating into society, as demonstrated by his personal journey (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). A significant finding of my research is that veterans’ self-perceptions are profoundly influenced by the military culture, even after they have separated from the armed forces (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). The principles, structure, companionship, and standards that they acquired during their military service continue to influence their personal identities, worldviews, and interpersonal interactions in their daily lives.
Colin stated that the military’s ideals and ethos continue to significantly shape his identity. For example, he said that he does not always feel safe, but “it depends on who I’m talking to because I’m still aware of security” (p 15, line 334). This demonstrates how profoundly and irrevocably military culture shapes individuals’ identities. After further discussion with Colin, it became clear that the transition process involves an intricate negotiation between the previous military identity and the developing civilian one.
Challenge of Redefining Self Beyond Military Life
How individuals cope with the loss of community and structure in military life is an additional significant theme in my study. When individuals transition from military duty to civilian life, they give up the clear hierarchy, set routines, and shared sense of mission that defined their military experience (Sachdev & Dixit, 2023). Colin reflects on this loss, stating, “The Sergeants’ Mess – you can’t beat it, there’s nothing like it, absolutely nothing like it. So for comradeship, working as a team, you taking great joy in supporting other people, other people supporting you, being grateful for that – um there’s no other organization that does it” (p 4, lane 60). Colin’s statement about his sense of disorientation and lack of community and structure demonstrates how challenging it is for them to adapt to a mundane existence devoid of comparable social support and organization (Meca et al., 2021). A central concept in my reevaluation of identity was the necessity for daily existence to acquire a fresh significance.
The lack of organization not only influences social connections but also affects the mental health of veterans such as Colin. During our conversations, it became evident that the transfer typically leads to an identity gap previously supplied by the military environment (Sachdev & Dixit, 2023). Colin expressed feeling lost without the military’s defined goals and companionship; he said, “I felt a bit of a culture shock” (p. 8, line 168). He explained that the military’s mission-oriented attitude offers a sense of purpose that is difficult to recreate in civilian life. The lack of purpose leads to a lack of drive and a sense of directionlessness, which many veterans find hard to articulate or resolve.
Coping with Loss of Community and Structure
Role of Comradeship in Military Identity
In Colin’s reflections on his military experiences and transition to civilian life, a major theme is coping with the loss of community and structure. Colin’s statement about soldiers having to re-learn how to stand on their own after leaving the military underscores the harsh reality of moving from a tight-knit community to civilian life. His words, “You can’t be expected to be… held by the hand,” emphasize the expectation of self-sufficiency rooted in military culture (p. 13, line 287).
The rest of the interview shows how a military identity can affect civilian interactions. Colin’s intentional choice to open up about his military experience underscores the challenges of navigating social and professional spheres outside the Army. In addition, Colin’s call for better support for returning veterans underscores the difficulty many face in finding their place in a civilian society (p 20, line 446). His desire for a well-rounded veterans’ office echoes the need for community and continued structure after military service.
Adjusting to the Lack of Organizational Support in Civilian Life
The story documents the profound change from military to civilian life, marked by the loss of community structure and support. Colin’s self-analysis reveals the full complexity of this journey. He laments that he did not further his military education: “I regret that I didn’t take advantage of doing further education while I was in the army” (p. 12, line 273). He acknowledges the need for self-sufficiency after service, highlighting the Army’s role in strengthening independence.
Nevertheless, Colin’s integration into civilian employment underscores the struggle to reconcile his military self with his civilian aspirations. He selectively divulges his military background, orienting his social relationships to avoid obstacles. For instance, regarding the incident in the hospital, he says, “I’m not after compensation but at least some sort of sympathetic view because I think, as servicemen, we have a special place in society, of having served our country” (p. 19, line 428). His thirst for camaraderie and the sense of purpose of military life stand in direct contrast to the mundanity of his civilian job, displaying a keen yearning for the past. Despite the adaptation, Colin finds relief in supportive family relationships, especially in his wife’s unflinching support.
Discussion
The results of my study regarding the psychological renegotiation of identities by former soldiers contribute to our understanding of the transition from military service to civilian life. The themes I identified are similar to those in previous scholarly publications on the issue (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). They illustrate the difficulty that servicemen face during this critical period in their lives (Ahern et al., 2015). The findings underscore the critical need to provide soldiers with tailored assistance and services that address their unique requirements, thereby facilitating their seamless reintegration into civilian society.
A drawback of my study is that it was limited to a single interview recording, which merely illustrates the experience of one individual. While Colin’s story is deep and detailed, it may not fully capture the range of situations that ex-combatants face as they redefine themselves (Kleykamp et al., 2021). Such a constraint underscores the need to expand my future research to encompass a broader spectrum of transitional circumstances and challenges faced by veterans (Binks & Cambridge, 2017). An analysis could be carried out to examine the impact of factors such as personal circumstances, branch of service, and duration of service on the process of renegotiating one’s identity and adapting to civilian life by increasing the sample size (Kleykamp et al., 2021).
References
Ahern, J., Worthen, M. E., Masters, J., Lippman, S. A., Ozer, E. J., & Moos, R. H. (2015). The Challenges of Afghanistan and Iraq Veterans’ Transition from Military to Civilian Life and Approaches to Reconnection. PLOS ONE, 10(7).
Binks, E., & Cambridge, S. (2017). The transition experiences of British military veterans. Political Psychology, 39(1), 125–142.
Dolan, G., McCauley, M., & Murphy, D. (2022). Factors Influencing the salience of Military/Veteran Identity post Discharge: A scoping review. Journal of Veterans Studies, 8(1), 231.
Endicott, T. W. (2022). Veteran social identity, partisanship, and political behavior. Politics, Groups & Identities/Politics, Groups, and Identities, 11(4), 813–833.
Kleykamp, M., Montgomery, S., Pang, A., & Schrader, K. (2021). Military identity and planning for the transition out of the military. Military Psychology, 33(6), 372–391.
Lev‐Ari, R. K., Solomon, Z., & Horesh, D. (2020). Far away, so close: The role of self‐differentiation in psychopathology among spouses of ex‐POWs and comparable combatants. Journal of Clinical Psychology (Print), 76(10), 1904–1922.
Meca, A., Allison, K. K., Ayers, K. L., Carr, K., Cox, S., Bravo, A. J., Davies, R. L., & Kelley, M. L. (2021). Understanding the unique effects of identity in adjustment among veterans. Military Behavioral Health, 9(4), 1–424.
Sachdev, S., & Dixit, S. (2023). Military to civilian cultural transition experiences of retired military personnel: A systematic meta-synthesis. Military Psychology, 1–14.